Questionable Comments

During the summer of 2017, the Digital Tattoo project team is collaborating with students and others on the development of case study scenarios for use in seminars in teacher education programs.

Workshop participants have the opportunity to:

  • build their confidence for decision-making about posting and sharing content online.
  • practice using guidelines and resources to support decision-making.
  • reflect on and discuss the multiple perspectives at play in each scenario and the implications for themselves as beginning teachers.

When used appropriately, social media can be a source of connection and community for teachers.


Table Discussion

In groups of 3-4:

1. Read the case study and consider your response to the personal reflection question as you read.

2. Discuss each question below with your group, using the resources to support your responses.

3. Take notes on your discussion to share when the large group reconvenes.


While reading the case study, consider your personal response to the following question:

How would I respond to seeing a fellow teacher or teacher candidate make inappropriate comments through social media?


someone texting - hand on a cell phone

Before beginning their practicums, a group of teacher candidates who were placed in the same school to teach created a private Facebook group and a group chat through text so that they could share resources, discuss their experiences, and plan times to get together outside of school. Because they were all trying to monitor their use of social media in order to avoid breaching any policies, they decided to communicate through these private groups, as opposed to posting on any public profiles. Recognizing that they could help one another succeed by monitoring their social media interactions, all of the teacher candidates agreed not to post comments about each other or share any photos from their parties without asking for permission, especially if they were drinking alcohol or wearing revealing clothing that they would not wear while teaching.


When they began their practicums, the Facebook group and group chat were primarily used to share resources and suggestions for their teaching, and arrange meeting times and places for their parties and meet-ups. As the practicum progressed, however, the teacher candidates became more stressed because of their workloads and frustrated by some of their experiences, and this became evident in their social media conversations. Common experiences included disruptions and disrespect from students, difficult interactions with school advisors, and administrators that teacher candidates did not enjoy working with, and some members of the group began using the social media groups as a way to vent about these situations and let off steam. One particular teacher candidate, Mark, finds his ninth grade science class to be consistently unmotivated and difficult to manage and he feels unfairly scrutinized by his school advisor for his inability to maintain control of the class at times. He feels that her criticisms are unearned, especially because she often leaves the classroom for long periods of time during his lessons and is not there to help him find better ways to manage the students when they will not complete their schoolwork. Mark has started expressing his frustration to his fellow teacher candidates through their texts and Facebook conversations, making comments like “I hope these kids enjoy their jobs at McDonald's--they’ll be working there forever at this rate” and “Seriously, if this woman is in charge of evaluating me, SHE SHOULD STAY IN THE ROOM WHILE I TEACH!” One day, while his students are working on an assignment, and while he is grading their most recent tests, he takes photos of some of his students’ wrong answers and later sends them to the group message, saying “These kids are such idiots sometimes. Maybe if they tried paying attention in class they wouldn’t give answers like these on tests!”


Maria, another teacher candidate in the group, understands his frustration about the difficulties of managing students in the classroom and getting support from other teachers; however, she also feels that the comments he makes are inappropriate--even if the students and other teachers can’t see them--and that they might represent professional misconduct for a certified teacher. Because she is a part of the group, Maria is worried that not saying or doing anything about Mark's posts could suggest that she agrees with the things he says and encourage him to continue sending these kinds of messages. At the same time, she considers Mark a friend and she recognizes the need for teacher candidates to protect one another. She does not want to upset her fellow teacher candidates, especially Mark, by sharing the texts and Facebook posts with their facilitator or the school administrators, but she is also not comfortable ignoring them, especially if her name is associated with the group messages.


1. Are Mark's comments, made through private text exchanges and Facebook groups, a violation of social media policies and/or the Teacher Education Office’s practicum guidelines? Can comments like these be grounds for discipline? Who could be impacted by Mark's messages?

Consider these resources as you answer:

  • Refer to "Professional Conduct for Teacher Candidates," which begins on page 4.
  • Read guidelines 1 through 4.4.


2. What would you do in Maria's situation? Is it reasonable for her to consider sharing the messages she deems inappropriate? What should she consider when making a decision?

Consider these resources as you answer:

  • Read "Background and Facts" on pages 1-2.


3. To what extent can teachers expect privacy when communicating digitally? What should teachers consider before sending messages to colleagues through social media?

Consider these resources as you answer:

  • Read the "Why Be Concerned?" and "Guidelines and Advice" sections.
  • Read "Minimizing the Risk: Advice to Members" on pages 6-7.
  • Read "The Inappropriate E-mail Incident" on page 10.


4. What are the benefits of communicating with other teachers and teacher candidates through social media? How would you use social media to connect with colleagues and how would you ensure that it is used effectively and appropriately?

Consider these resources as you answer:


If time allows, explore these additional resources:

  • Read "Professional Conduct Advisory: Professional Boundaries and Social Media” on page 14.


Some rights reserved Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document according to the terms in Creative Commons License, Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0. The full text of this license may be found here: CC by-sa 4.0 Attribution-Share-a-like


When re-using this resource, please attribute as follows: developed by the University of British Columbia: Digital Tattoo – Case Studies Project Team.

This represents the number of times this page has been viewed since its creation:0

What questions did this case study raise for you from your perspective? Please share in the comment box below.

source: http://wiki.ubc.ca/Documentation:Digital_Tattoo_Questionable_Comments

Post image: Group texting, licensed CC0 1.0 on Pixabay.com

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.